| Date | Individual/Organisation | Feedback and suggestions | Action |
| 18 February 2013 |
Philippe Caroff, Meteo-France |
Addition of disturbance development types. Added post-tropical depression and remnant low to development enumeration. |
|
| 25 January 2008 |
Tim Hewson, Met Office
|
Add elements to represent extratropical
cyclone diagnostics as done in the Met Office's cyclone database (click
here to see list of
diagnostics) |
|
| 29 January 2008 |
Nick Bower, RPS Metocean Engineers
|
In creating a schema and namespace, CXML is not just a
standard format for data exchange, but also a way to mix standard with
local storage and analysis requirements in a way not possible with
previous formats.
Users can provide local additional enrichment to CXML based data
without corrupting the standard, or even add CXML constructs to
existing XML data. |
(none) |
| 30 January 2008 |
John Knaff, CIRA
|
Add elements to represent multiple fixes from different
platforms, multiple radii of maximum wind and eye diameters,
environmental pressure and tangential winds at fixed radii (say 500km,
1000km). |
Done (v.0.2) |
| 2 February 2008 |
John Knaff, CIRA
|
Include confidence/accuracy information on fix data |
Done (v.0.2) |
| 4 February 2008 |
Bruce Harper, Systems Engineering Australia
|
Include averaging times with wind measurements and estimates |
Done (v.0.2) |
| 5 February 2008 |
Jeff Kepert, Bureau of Meteorology
|
Allow for estimates of precision and/or rounding. Include greater
detail on Dvorak parameters |
Precision added (v.0.2) |
| 8 February 2008 |
Tim Marchok, GFDL
|
Break the model resolution into 2 separate identifiers,
one for model resolution and one for gridded output data resolution |
Done (v.0.2) |
| 12 February 2008 |
Ian Shepherd, Bureau of Meteorology
|
Tropical cyclone nomenclature is different for different regions
and are based on different wind averaging periods.
A system can be defined uniquely by its wind speed range and wind averaging period.
|
Many nomenclatures available for use in CXML |
| 15 February 2008 |
Samuel Westrelin, Meteo-France
|
This XML format appears to be a good opportunity to get a consensus
on the cyclone ID, which varies for different organizations |
no consensus yet |
| 18 February 2008 |
Justin Ma, HKO
|
Provide detailed description of all parameters to avoid
mis-interpretation |
Draft CXML manual written |
| 21 February 2008 |
Chris Sisko, NHC
|
The proposal for CXML has merit and if the
format specification is clearly and extensively documented, I believe that CXML would be widely
adopted and could be provided in real-time for external use. Click
here
for full comments, and
here
for replies. |
(none) |
| 22 February 2008 |
Andrew Burton, Bureau of Meteorology
|
Expanded Dvorak parameters
|
Done (v.0.2) |
| 3 March 2008 |
Philippe Caroff, MeteoFrance
|
Include all items in
WMO Best Track format (2002)
|
source attribute added to record observations
source for various cyclone data |
| 11 May 2008 |
Mike Charles, NCEP
|
Include information on tracking domain
|
Optional trackingDomain element added to metadata |
| 4 June 2008 |
Mike Charles, NCEP
|
Include continent names in subregions to enable extra-tropical cyclone tracking
|
Continents added to list of allowable subregions (v.1.0) |
| 17 June 2008 |
Baudouin Raoult, ECMWF
|
basin element differs from the WMO basin abbreviations in the file names.
Units should be enforced for consistency.
|
Basin names modified to be consistent with WMO documents (v.1.1),
units specifically enumerated |
| 24 August 2009 |
Philippe Caroff, Meteo-France
|
Source of data for radius of maximum winds should be described.
|
(v.1.2) radius element now includes an optional source attribute.
|